The Misery Index & The Impact On Business

by Paul Simister on October 29, 2011

The Misery Index is a term which is gaining popularity in the press as economic problems and social unrest increase in 2011.

What is The Misery Index?

The misery index is a composite measure made up of two important measures of economic activity:

  • The unemployment rate
  • The inflation rate

The misery index was created by economist Arthur Okun in the 1970s. Harvard economist Robert Barro created the Barro Misery Index also in the 1970s which also included GDP and the bank rate.

When I first studied economics in the mid-seventies, it was thought that there was a trade-off between unemployment and inflation. As one increased, the other was supposed to reduce according to the Phillips curve suggesting a fairly constant misery index.

While it was a nice theory connected to supply and demand

  • if demand exceeded supply, then prices would increase but unemployment should reduce as the incentives to increase supply improved; and
  • if supply exceeded demand, then prices would fall but unemployment would increase as actions were taken to reduce supply

a look at the economic data showed that the link wasn’t strong and the misery index raises and falls.

The Misery Index Across The World

MoneyWeek magazine (28 October 100) reported the misery index across the world’s leading nations.

The Countries With the Lowest Misery Index

  • Switzerland 3.50
  • Japan 4.80
  • Norway 4.90
  • Mexico 8.37
  • Australia 8.80

The Countries With The Highest Misery Index

  • South Africa 28.90
  • Spain 23.99
  • Greece 19.23
  • India 18.39
  • Argentina 17.20

The UK has a rating of 13.30 and the United States 13.00.

The Impact Of The Misery Index On Business

The misery index affects confidence. As it increases, consumers and businesses as investors become less confident about the future, increasing the likelihood of delaying spending decisions and increasing saving. As people become less confident of the general economy, the natural inclination is to put about some rainy day money although doing it may become harder because incomes are squeezed.

Different parts of the economy are affected in different ways by increases in the misery index.

As the unemployment element increases, people who are unemployed find it more difficult to get a job and those in employment fear that they may lose their jobs. This aspect of the misery index won’t affect those who are already retired.

As inflation increases, consumers incomes will buy fewer goods and services unless their incomes rise in line or faster than inflation. If unemployment is high, bargaining power of employees to protect their standard of living is weak meaning those in work are likely to have their incomes squeezed and be forced to either cut back on consumption or to increase their personal debt to maintain lifestyles. Increasing debt when unemployment risks are high is risky.

Those retired may be protected against inflation if their pension plans are linked to an inflation index although there will be discrepancies between the index and pensioners’ own purchases. Many pensioners may have a fixed income without any link to inflation and even worse, those without annuities who rely on investment income are squeezed by the record low interest rates.

The misery index creates a feeling of helplessness. Consumers want and need more income to keep up with inflation but unemployment keeps the wage pressures suppressed and there are few opportunities to supplement income with overtime and secondary part time jobs. Individuals who can afford to save are likely to build up a “worst case” reserve but while this makes sense for the individual consumer, it further weakens confidence in the economy as the reduced consumption causes businesses to cutback further on employment.

The Misery Index and Business Strategy

Both unemployment and inflation should be considered in the PEST Analysis. I believe the misery index is worth adding in as an extra measure to monitor since the statistic related to confidence.

Wikipedia has an interesting analysis of the misery index across the presidents in the USA. It shows how troubled the seventies were with Nixon, Ford and Carter. To some extent, there is a time lag between the actions which cause inflation and unemployment and it showing through in measurements. For example, unemployment is a lagging indicator of recessions.

Paul Simister is a business strategy coach who helps business owners to differentiate their businesses and develop winning strategies. Get your free copy of my ebook The Six Steps Profit Formula.

The Best Of The Differentiate Your Business Blog

If you’ve enjoyed this article about the misery index, I think you’ll enjoy these popular articles:

Industry Value Chain Analysis – How Different Combinations Create Value For Customers

How To Assess Your Strategic Position With The SPACE Matrix

PEST – The Impact Of Political, Economic, Social And Technological Changes

Scenario Planning And Uncertainty

Should Strategy Be Developed From The Outside In Or Inside Out?

What is Strategy?

How Much Will Your Business Results Improve When You Know More About The Strategies For Profitable Growth?

I invite you to take a 30 day trial of my small business growth membership club at ProfitableGrowthStrategies.org so that you can see for yourself the benefit of applying more and better strategies and tactics for profitable growth.

misery index

{ 2 comments }

Debbie October 31, 2011 at 6:17 pm

I think it’s interesting to notice how many more different indexes there are when things are going badly. We all want to know who is worse off than ourselves. But I quite like this concept- it makes sense to me.

Paul Simister November 1, 2011 at 6:37 am

I think the misery index helps us to rationalise our feelings about how tough things are at the moment. Of course it doesn’t help when you turn on the TV or radio and the news has story after story of misery – economic disasters, natural disasters, social unrest and crime…

Comments on this entry are closed.

Previous post:

Next post: